By Andrew Chung
August 3 (Reuters) – U.S. Supreme Courtroom Justice Sonia Sotomayor declined on Monday to halt $655.5 million in damages that Palestinian authorities have been ordered to pay plaintiffs in a U.S. civil lawsuit regarding assaults that killed and injured Individuals in Israel from 2002 to 2004.
Sotomayor denied a request by the Palestinian Authority and the Palestine Liberation Group to placed on maintain the judgment whereas they enchantment a decrease court docket’s choice to revive the case years after it had been dismissed. The lawsuit was introduced on behalf of Individuals killed or injured in these shootings and bombings within the Jerusalem space.
The Supreme Courtroom final 12 months upheld a federal legislation that allowed claims like these introduced by the plaintiffs within the case.
Sotomayor didn’t clarify her choice and didn’t refer the case to all the court docket. Sotomayor handles emergency issues for instances arising from New York and sure different states.
The Manhattan-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals reinstated the judgment in March following the Supreme Courtroom’s 9-0 choice in June 2025 to uphold the 2019 legislation, referred to as the Selling Safety and Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act.
The Palestinian organizations mentioned that implementing the judgment within the case will trigger extreme monetary hurt and destabilize authorities companies within the West Financial institution, harming individuals who stay there and jeopardizing regional safety.
They mentioned in a written submitting that the plaintiffs intend to hunt cost from oblique Palestinian tax income collected by Israel, a key supply of funding for Palestinian authorities operations. Safety, sanitation and college companies within the West Financial institution “are hanging by a thread,” they wrote.
The plaintiffs, in successful the judgment in New York federal court docket in 2015, alleged that the Palestinian entities have been chargeable for the incidents from 2002 to 2004.
The 2nd Circuit threw out that verdict in 2016 and ordered that the case be dismissed, concluding that the federal decide within the case didn’t have jurisdiction over the matter. The Supreme Courtroom declined to listen to an enchantment of the case in 2018.
Congress then handed the 2019 legislation to facilitate lawsuits towards Palestinian authorities. Underneath the legislation, the PLO and Palestinian Authority routinely “consent” to jurisdiction in the event that they conduct sure actions in the USA or make funds to individuals who assault Individuals.
The 2nd Circuit subsequently determined that the 2019 legislation violated the rights of those Palestinian authorities to due course of beneath the U.S. Structure. However the Supreme Courtroom overturned that ruling final 12 months.
Following that Supreme Courtroom motion, the 2nd Circuit resurrected the judgment for the plaintiffs.
The Palestinian authorities urged the Supreme Courtroom to halt the cost for now, saying the judgment had lengthy change into void and a “nullity.”
“The cash judgment at challenge grew to become a authorized nullity when … appeals have been exhausted in 2018,” they mentioned.
(Reporting by Andrew Chung; Enhancing by Will Dunham)
AL-MONITOR All-Entry provides you limitless entry to all our journalism, the total Every day Briefing, unique interviews, premium newsletters, and stay occasions — for lower than $2/week.
